How to Hire a Health and Safety Manager: The Complete Employer Guide

Hiring a Health and Safety Manager is one of the most important decisions a business can make. The right person strengthens culture, reduces incidents, improves compliance and drives operational performance. The wrong hire increases risk, slows teams down and can quietly cost the business far more than the salary attached to the role.

This guide explains how to hire the right H&S Manager, the qualifications to look for, how to assess competence and the interview questions that help you separate strong operators from people who look good on paper only.

To download this guide as a PDF document, please see the link below.

How to hire a Health and Safety Manager - The Complete Employers Guide.pdf

Download PDF • 434KB

When Do You Actually Need a Health and Safety Manager?

Every organisation reaches a point where informal / ad-hoc arrangements or part time responsibilities are no longer enough. You should consider hiring a dedicated H&S Manager when any of the following apply:

• You have grown past fifty employees or are scaling to multiple sites.

• The organisation is taking on higher risk work such as construction, manufacturing, infrastructure or engineering.

• Clients or insurers require a named H&S lead.

• You are implementing or maintaining ISO 45001.

• You have experienced incidents, claims or enforcement notices.

• You want to improve engagement, culture and training consistency.

Good safety management is preventative. Hiring before a problem occurs is always cheaper than responding after the event.

Key Responsibilities of a Health and Safety Manager

Although responsibilities vary by sector, most H&S Manager roles fall into four areas.

Strategy

• Planning annual objectives and priorities.

• Monitoring performance against KPIs.

• Developing improvement plans.

• Working with senior leadership on risk.

Operational Delivery

• Site inspections and audits.

• Supporting teams with risk assessments.

• Leading investigations and corrective actions.

• Training, toolbox talks and briefings.

• Contractor control and permit processes.

Systems and Compliance

• Updating policies and procedures.

• Managing legal registers and reporting obligations.

• Supporting ISO 45001 and external audits.

• Ensuring documentation reflects real work practice.

Engagement and Culture

• Influencing managers and supervisors.

• Building relationships with operations and projects.

• Coaching teams rather than policing them.

• Helping the business understand practical risk.

This balance is important. Strong H&S Managers are not paperwork administrators. They are operational partners.

What Qualifications Should You Look For

Qualifications help with benchmarking, although certificates alone do not guarantee competence.

Essential

• NEBOSH General Certificate as a baseline.

• NEBOSH Diploma or NVQ Level 6 for more senior roles

Desirable

• IOSH Membership (not critically essential, but often seen as additional credibility) 

• Fire qualifications such as Fire Manager or relevant FRA training (if applicable for your business)

• IEMA or environmental training if the remit includes sustainability.

• Quality or ISO skills such as Internal / Lead Auditor.

The real non-negotiables

• Experience in the tasks you need someone carrying out, also relatable industry or risk profile experience.

• Evidence and examples of engaging and influencing operational teams.

• A practical approach that avoids unnecessary bureaucracy.

• Clarity of communication and confidence dealing with managers.

A good H&S Manager improves workflow and removes friction.

How to Assess a Candidate’s Competence

This is the section most employers get wrong. Technical qualifications matter but they do not tell you how a candidate behaves on site or how they operate under pressure.

Here is how to assess competence properly.

Ask for real examples

Request examples of:

• Risk assessments they have written.

• Investigations they have led.

• Improvements they have delivered.

• Culture initiatives or behavioural programmes.

Good candidates can talk through their work in a practical way without hiding behind jargon.

Look for commercial awareness

Competent H&S Managers understand:

• Budgets and the cost of incidents.

• How insurance claims work.

• How to prioritise when everything feels urgent.

• The operational reality of deadlines and productivity pressures.

Test influence and communication

Safety only works if people listen. Strong candidates can explain how they have influenced a reluctant manager or coached a team that pushed back.

Assess resilience

Many H&S Managers become disengaged when their advice is repeatedly ignored. The best ones understand how to build relationships and create buy in even in imperfect situations.

Salary Guide for Health and Safety Managers in the UK

Salary is influenced by sector, size and location. As a general guide:

• H&S Advisor: £35k to £55k.

• H&S Manager: £45k to £70k.

• Senior H&S Manager: £60k to £75k.

• Head of HSEQ: £75k to £100k plus.

Roles in London or high risk industries often pay above these figures. Interim day rates typically range from £300 to £600 depending on scope.

Interview Questions That Separate High Performers

Use open questions that reveal how a candidate thinks and behaves.

1. Tell me about a time you influenced a manager who disagreed with your recommendation.

1. Describe an investigation you led and explain what changed afterwards.

1. What does good safety culture look like in a practical, everyday sense.

1. How do you prioritise when several issues demand attention at the same time.

1. Give me an example of a measurable improvement you delivered.

1. How do you adapt your approach when you see early signs of disengagement.

Listen for clarity, ownership and evidence of real impact.

Red Flags to Watch For

Be cautious if a candidate:

• Blames incidents solely on worker behaviour without considering system failure.

• Talks only about policies and procedures with limited operational examples.

• Cannot explain measurable results.

• Struggles to describe conflict or influencing situations.

• Speaks negatively about previous employers without any reflection or context.

These are indicators of poor fit, limited experience or potential disengagement.

Where to Find Good Health and Safety Managers

Most strong candidates are passive not active job seekers. You will find the highest quality talent through:

• Specialist HSEQ recruitment agencies.

• Direct outreach on LinkedIn.

• Industry bodies and IOSH job boards.

• Referrals from operational teams or trusted peers.

• Promoting internally where there is potential for growth.

A targeted approach usually outperforms general job boards.

How Search² Supports Employers

We specialise in recruiting Health, Safety, Fire, Environmental, Quality and Risk professionals across the UK. Our network includes experienced advisors, managers and senior leaders across construction, manufacturing, infrastructure, facilities management, renewables, energy and consultancy.

We focus on hiring people who strengthen culture, reduce risk and add practical value to operations. If you need support hiring a Health and Safety Manager, speak with us directly and we will guide you through the process.

Information about our services:

Health and Safety Recruitment

Environment, ESG and Environmental Recruitment

Quality Recruitment

ISO Management System Recruitment

Fire Safety Recruitment

Risk Management Recruitment

To get in contact with us: 

Website: www.search-recruitment.co.uk

Email: info@search-recruitment.co.uk 

Phone: 020 4592 1645

To register a vacancy with us:

Register a vacancy